Israelis marked three years since the Oct. 7 attacks on Wednesday, mourning at the places where people were killed and taken hostage as Netanyahu faced renewed scrutiny over whether he had received warnings beforehand. For Palestinians grappling with the ensuing war, the anniversary also marked the continuing consequences of the conflict the attacks triggered. The commemorations brought together questions of remembrance, political accountability and security against the backdrop of a Middle East reshaped by the fighting.

Ceremonies have taken place at homes, along roadsides, in kibbutzim and at the Nova music festival site, where militants killed more than 360 people and took 44 hostages. The consequences now extend well beyond those locations: more than 300,000 Lebanese remain displaced, Israel has seized territory in Lebanon and Syria, and the United States has joined Israel in two rounds of attacks on Iran’s military and nuclear programme. Those figures describe different aspects of a conflict whose reach has expanded far beyond its opening attacks.

The commemorations at individual sites retain a local focus within that wider regional picture. Homes, roadsides, kibbutzim and a festival ground provide multiple settings through which the attacks are being remembered. The Nova figures give a specific measure of the violence there, encompassing both killings and hostage-taking. They are figures for that site, not a count covering every location targeted on Oct. 7, a distinction important to understanding the scope of the anniversary observances.

Read more: Houthis strike Saudi targets as West Bank harvesters come under fire

For Netanyahu, the anniversary has also renewed a dispute over what he knew before the attacks. Reports that he had been warned have prompted questions about his handling of the threat. He has denied receiving such warnings, describing the reports as “fake news”. Last week, he filed a defamation lawsuit over the reports. His response places the allegations in a legal dispute as well as a political one, without resolving the underlying disagreement about what information reached him.

The distinction between an allegation and an established account is central to that dispute. Claims that Netanyahu received warnings raise questions about the period before the attacks, but his denial directly contests their premise. The filing of a lawsuit sets out his opposition to the reports; it does not by itself determine whether they are accurate. The competing accounts therefore remain part of the anniversary’s unresolved debate, alongside the more immediate task of commemorating those killed and those taken hostage.

That debate also has an electoral setting, with Netanyahu facing scrutiny over Oct. 7 in an Israeli election. The question of advance warning concerns his conduct before the attacks, while the anniversary draws attention to the consequences that followed. These are related but distinct issues: an account of what officials knew would address preparedness, whereas an assessment of the subsequent wars concerns decisions made after the attacks. Neither question can be answered solely by the scale of the regional conflict that has since developed.

Read more: Trump heads to San Antonio for Paxton as Democrats eye Texas Senate opening

Netanyahu and his defense minister have also issued new warnings about Hamas. Those statements place a continuing security concern alongside the dispute over earlier warnings. They do not settle the argument about the period before Oct. 7, but they underline the different time frames confronting Israel at the anniversary: remembering the attacks, examining the decisions that preceded them and considering threats that officials say remain. The political challenge is consequently not confined to a retrospective argument about a single moment.

For Palestinians, the anniversary also marks the consequences of the war the attacks set off. That experience sits alongside, rather than within, Israel’s commemorations of the original assault. The anniversary thus carries different meanings for communities affected by the conflict: Israelis are gathering at attack sites, while Palestinians confront the consequences of the ensuing war. Keeping those experiences distinct is necessary to describe both, without treating mourning for the attacks as a complete account of the conflict that followed.

The regional background has changed substantially during those three years. Israel has fought Hamas, Hezbollah and their backer Iran in a succession of conflicts set in motion by Oct. 7. That expansion means the anniversary concerns more than the relationship between Israel and Gaza. It also falls against a record of fighting involving other armed groups and states, with consequences for territory, displacement and international military involvement. The original attacks remain the point of commemoration, but the wars they triggered have acquired a much broader geography.

In Lebanon, more than 300,000 people remain displaced. The figure describes continuing disruption, not simply movement that occurred during an earlier phase of fighting. It also provides a different measure of the conflict from the deaths and hostage-taking recorded at Nova. These numbers should not be combined or treated as interchangeable: one concerns people who remain displaced, while the others describe what happened at a particular attack site. Together, they illustrate why the regional consequences cannot be captured by a single measure.

Israel’s seizure of territory in Syria and Lebanon adds a territorial dimension to that picture. The significance is distinct from displacement, even though both form part of the changed regional setting. The anniversary is taking place not only after fighting across borders but also after Israel took control of areas beyond its own territory. That development broadens the context in which questions about security and Netanyahu’s leadership are being considered, beyond the immediate circumstances of the attacks and the war in Gaza.

The United States’ participation in two rounds of attacks on Iran’s military and nuclear programme represents another expansion of the conflict. It places direct American military involvement alongside Israel’s confrontation with Iran and its allied groups. The description of two rounds establishes repeated participation, but does not provide a measure of damage or an outcome for Iran’s nuclear programme. The relevant point for the anniversary is the widening involvement of states in a sequence of wars that began with the Oct. 7 attacks.

What comes next is framed by several unresolved questions rather than a single anniversary milestone. Netanyahu’s lawsuit contests the warning reports, the Israeli election provides a political setting for scrutiny of his leadership, and his government’s warnings about Hamas keep attention on security. Meanwhile, Palestinians grapple with the consequences of war and displaced Lebanese remain away from home. Three years on, remembrance and accountability are proceeding alongside the consequences of wars that have transformed the region, with neither the dispute over advance warnings nor the broader human cost settled by the commemorations.